Line Item SupplyIndustrial Equipment
Request a Quote

Energy and payback

Equipment ROI: payback, NPV, and IRR after tax

Cost, yearly savings or revenue, running cost, the depreciation and tax rate, your cost of money, and the life in; the after-tax cash flow by year, payback, net present value, and internal rate of return.

Read the guide: what the number means and how to use it

  • After-tax cash flow each year = (savings − operating cost) × (1 − tax rate) + depreciation × tax rate, with salvage after tax in the last year. Savings grow at the rate given.
  • NPV discounts each year's flow at the cost of money and subtracts the cost; IRR is the discount rate at which NPV is zero (solved by bisection); payback is when cumulative cash turns positive, simple and discounted.

Need it quoted?

See what the first-year deduction does to the payback on the same purchase.

Section 179

Equipment ROI, NPV, IRR

year 143,960 $year 220,851 $year 321,563 $

Net present value at 10%

78,929 $

worth doing at your cost of money

Internal rate of return

30.8 %

the return the cash flows earn

After-tax payback

2.9 years

3.8 years discounted

After-tax cash flow, year 1
43,960 $includes the depreciation tax shield
Year 2
20,851 $
Year 3
21,563 $
Total after-tax cash over 10 years
262,728 $309% of the cost back
Simple pre-tax payback
3 years

One line for the file or the vendor

$85,000, saves $32,000/yr (+3%/yr) less $4,000, 10 yrs, tax 28%, expensed year 1, discount 10%: NPV $78,929, IRR 30.8%, payback 2.9 yrs.

Keep this result, or have it priced

One email with what you asked for. No list, no newsletter.

How it is figured

  • After-tax cash flow each year = (savings − operating cost) × (1 − tax rate) + depreciation × tax rate, with salvage after tax in the last year. Savings grow at the rate given.
  • NPV discounts each year's flow at the cost of money and subtracts the cost; IRR is the discount rate at which NPV is zero (solved by bisection); payback is when cumulative cash turns positive, simple and discounted.

Sources: Standard capital budgeting (NPV, IRR, payback); IRS Publication 946 for the MACRS percentages. A planning calculator; the maker, the engineer of record, or the code official confirms the final number.

Questions people ask

NPV or payback?
Payback is what most plants decide on, and under three years is an easy yes. NPV tells you what the project is worth in today's dollars and catches the long-lived equipment that pays back slowly but earns for 15 years. IRR lets you compare it with the loan rate. Show all three; they agree more often than not.
Where do the savings come from?
Count what you can document: labor hours at the loaded rate, energy from the bill, damage and product loss from the incident log, throughput at the margin. Leave out what you cannot prove. A dock leveler that ends a 20-minute delay per trailer on 30 trailers a day is 10 labor hours a day, and that is the kind of number that holds up.

Related calculators: MACRS depreciation schedule, Simple payback, Section 179 calculator. All calculators.