Energy and payback
Equipment ROI: payback, NPV, and IRR after tax
Cost, yearly savings or revenue, running cost, the depreciation and tax rate, your cost of money, and the life in; the after-tax cash flow by year, payback, net present value, and internal rate of return.
Read the guide: what the number means and how to use it
- After-tax cash flow each year = (savings − operating cost) × (1 − tax rate) + depreciation × tax rate, with salvage after tax in the last year. Savings grow at the rate given.
- NPV discounts each year's flow at the cost of money and subtracts the cost; IRR is the discount rate at which NPV is zero (solved by bisection); payback is when cumulative cash turns positive, simple and discounted.
Need it quoted?
See what the first-year deduction does to the payback on the same purchase.
Section 179Equipment ROI, NPV, IRR
Net present value at 10%
78,929 $
worth doing at your cost of money
Internal rate of return
30.8 %
the return the cash flows earn
After-tax payback
2.9 years
3.8 years discounted
- After-tax cash flow, year 1
- 43,960 $includes the depreciation tax shield
- Year 2
- 20,851 $
- Year 3
- 21,563 $
- Total after-tax cash over 10 years
- 262,728 $309% of the cost back
- Simple pre-tax payback
- 3 years
One line for the file or the vendor
$85,000, saves $32,000/yr (+3%/yr) less $4,000, 10 yrs, tax 28%, expensed year 1, discount 10%: NPV $78,929, IRR 30.8%, payback 2.9 yrs.
How it is figured
- After-tax cash flow each year = (savings − operating cost) × (1 − tax rate) + depreciation × tax rate, with salvage after tax in the last year. Savings grow at the rate given.
- NPV discounts each year's flow at the cost of money and subtracts the cost; IRR is the discount rate at which NPV is zero (solved by bisection); payback is when cumulative cash turns positive, simple and discounted.
Sources: Standard capital budgeting (NPV, IRR, payback); IRS Publication 946 for the MACRS percentages. A planning calculator; the maker, the engineer of record, or the code official confirms the final number.
Questions people ask
- NPV or payback?
- Payback is what most plants decide on, and under three years is an easy yes. NPV tells you what the project is worth in today's dollars and catches the long-lived equipment that pays back slowly but earns for 15 years. IRR lets you compare it with the loan rate. Show all three; they agree more often than not.
- Where do the savings come from?
- Count what you can document: labor hours at the loaded rate, energy from the bill, damage and product loss from the incident log, throughput at the margin. Leave out what you cannot prove. A dock leveler that ends a 20-minute delay per trailer on 30 trailers a day is 10 labor hours a day, and that is the kind of number that holds up.
Related calculators: MACRS depreciation schedule, Simple payback, Section 179 calculator. All calculators.