Energy and payback · guide
Equipment ROI, NPV, IRR: the guide
After-tax cash flow, net present value, and internal rate of return are what a controller wants to see on a capital request; the calculator builds them from the savings, the taxes, and the cost of money.
Why this number matters
A purchase returns cash each year equal to its savings less its running cost, after tax, plus the tax it saves through depreciation; the depreciation shield is why expensing a purchase in year one makes its payback shorter in real terms. Net present value discounts each year's cash at the company's cost of money and subtracts the price; a positive NPV means the purchase earns more than the money would elsewhere. Internal rate of return is the discount rate at which NPV is zero, the project's own yield, to compare with the loan rate or the hurdle rate the company sets.
Simple payback is what most plants decide on and it is still here; discounted payback adds the time value. The three measures disagree only on long-lived purchases that pay slowly, which is where NPV earns its place: a dock equipment package that returns 20% a year for 12 years looks ordinary on payback and excellent on NPV.
The savings are the whole argument and the only part the arithmetic cannot supply. Labor hours at the loaded rate, energy from the calculators, damage and detention from the logs, throughput at the margin, each documented; a controller will test the biggest one first.
How it is figured
- After-tax cash flow each year = (savings − operating cost) × (1 − tax rate) + depreciation × tax rate, with salvage after tax in the last year. Savings grow at the rate given.
- NPV discounts each year's flow at the cost of money and subtracts the cost; IRR is the discount rate at which NPV is zero (solved by bisection); payback is when cumulative cash turns positive, simple and discounted.
A worked example
An $85,000 purchase saving $32,000 a year less $4,000 to run, growing 3% a year, expensed in year one at a 28% rate, over ten years at a 10% cost of money, returns about $27,000 after tax in year one, pays back in under three years, and has an NPV around $120,000 with an IRR near 35%.
The tool's starting values, and what it returns for them:
| Installed cost | 85,000 $ |
| Saves or earns per year, before tax | 32,000 $ |
| Costs to run per year | 4,000 $ |
| Savings growth per year | 3 % |
| Useful life | 10 years |
| Salvage at the end | 5,000 $ |
| Combined tax rate | 28 % |
| Depreciation | 100% in year one (Section 179 or bonus) |
| Discount rate, your cost of money | 10 % |
| Net present value at 10% | 78,929 $ |
| Internal rate of return | 30.8 % |
| After-tax payback | 2.9 years |
| After-tax cash flow, year 1 | 43,960 $ |
| Year 2 | 20,851 $ |
| Year 3 | 21,563 $ |
| Total after-tax cash over 10 years | 262,728 $ |
| Simple pre-tax payback | 3 years |
Mistakes that catch people
- Counting the depreciation shield twice, in the savings and in the cash flow.
- A discount rate of zero because the money is 'already there'.
- Forgetting the salvage, or counting it before tax.
Rules of thumb
- After-tax cash = (savings − opex) × (1 − t) + depreciation × t.
- NPV > 0 at your cost of money: worth doing. IRR > hurdle rate: same thing.
- Under 3 years of payback and positive NPV: an easy case.
When to stop calculating and make a call
- Purchases above the capital threshold: the finance team's template, which this matches in method.
- Financing decisions (lease versus buy): a different comparison.
Questions people ask
- NPV or payback?
- Payback is what most plants decide on, and under three years is an easy yes. NPV tells you what the project is worth in today's dollars and catches the long-lived equipment that pays back slowly but earns for 15 years. IRR lets you compare it with the loan rate. Show all three; they agree more often than not.
- Where do the savings come from?
- Count what you can document: labor hours at the loaded rate, energy from the bill, damage and product loss from the incident log, throughput at the margin. Leave out what you cannot prove. A dock leveler that ends a 20-minute delay per trailer on 30 trailers a day is 10 labor hours a day, and that is the kind of number that holds up.
Standards and sources
- Standard capital budgeting (NPV, IRR, payback); IRS Publication 946 for the MACRS percentages
This guide and the tool are planning aids. The equipment maker, the engineer of record, the accountant, or the code official confirms the final number for your building.