Energy and payback · guide
Simple payback: the guide
Payback is what the plant decides on: cost over net yearly benefit, and the five-year net says whether it keeps paying after it has paid for itself.
Why this number matters
Capital purchases in a plant are judged on how fast they return their cost, and the arithmetic is the installed cost less any rebate or tax saving in the first year, divided by what it saves or earns each year less what it costs to run. Under two years is approved at most companies without a fight; two to four needs the case written; longer competes with everything else on the list. The five- and ten-year nets show what the purchase is worth after it has paid for itself, which is where long-lived equipment like a dock leveler or an HVLS fan earns its keep.
The savings that hold up are the ones that can be documented: labor hours at the loaded rate, energy from the bill and the calculators, damage and product loss from the incident log, throughput at the margin, and avoided penalties like detention or a utility power factor charge. Safety savings are real but need the incidents written down.
This calculator is deliberately simple. The ROI calculator beside it adds taxes, depreciation, discounting, and IRR for the purchases that go in front of a controller.
How it is figured
- Net yearly benefit = savings − operating cost. Simple payback = (cost − year-one rebates) ÷ net benefit. Five- and ten-year nets subtract the investment from the cumulative benefit; annual return = net benefit ÷ investment. No discounting: it is the back-of-the-envelope most plant purchases are judged on.
A worked example
A $45,000 purchase that saves $18,000 a year and costs $2,000 to run nets $16,000 a year, pays back in 2.8 years, and is $35,000 ahead after five.
The tool's starting values, and what it returns for them:
| Installed cost | 45,000 $ |
| Saves or earns per year | 18,000 $ |
| Costs to run per year | 2,000 $ |
| Rebates and tax savings in year one | 0 $ |
| Useful life | 10 years |
| Simple payback | 2.8 years |
| Five-year net | 35,000 $ |
| Annual return | 36 % |
| Net benefit per year | 16,000 $ |
| Ten-year net | 115,000 $ |
| Net over the 10-year life | 115,000 $ |
Mistakes that catch people
- Counting gross savings and forgetting what the equipment costs to run.
- Claiming a labor saving that does not remove a person or a shift.
- Leaving the utility rebate and the Section 179 deduction out of year one.
Rules of thumb
- Under 2 years: approve. 2 to 4: write the case. Over 4: compete.
- Document the saving before you claim it.
- Payback ignores the life; the five-year net does not.
When to stop calculating and make a call
- Purchases over the capital threshold: the finance team wants NPV and IRR; use the ROI calculator.
- Savings that depend on behavior (speed limits, PM compliance): plan the program with the purchase.
Questions people ask
- What payback do plants accept?
- Under two years is usually approved on the spot; two to four needs a case; beyond that it competes with everything else. Safety and damage-avoidance savings are real but the plant has to believe the number, so document the incidents.
Standards and sources
- Standard capital budgeting arithmetic (simple payback, ROI)
This guide and the tool are planning aids. The equipment maker, the engineer of record, the accountant, or the code official confirms the final number for your building.