Line Item SupplyIndustrial Equipment
Request a Quote

Electrical · guide

LED retrofit payback: the guide

A metal halide high bay draws three times what an LED does for the same light; the payback is energy plus the ballasts and lamps you stop replacing, less the utility's rebate.

Open the calculator

Why this number matters

A 400-watt metal halide fixture draws about 458 watts with its ballast and loses a third of its light by mid-life; a 150- to 165-watt LED high bay matches it on the floor and holds its output for 50,000 hours. On a one-shift plant that is a saving of about 1,200 kWh a fixture a year; on 24/7 it is three times that. Maintenance is the quiet second saving: no lamps, no ballasts, no lift rental every 18 months.

The investment is the installed cost less the utility rebate, which in many territories runs $50 to $150 a fixture for a prescriptive retrofit, and the payback is that over the yearly saving. Demand charges shorten it further, since the kW reduction shows on every month's peak, and Section 179 or bonus depreciation turns most of the cost into a first-year deduction.

Controls add a second round: occupancy sensors in the aisles and daylight dimming by the docks typically take another 20 to 40% off the hours, and LED fixtures dim without complaint.

How it is figured

  • Energy saved = fixtures × (old − new watts) × hours ÷ 1000, times the rate. Maintenance saved is the lamp and ballast replacement no longer needed.
  • Payback = investment after rebates ÷ yearly savings. Demand charges and Section 179 expensing improve it further and are not included.

A worked example

Sixty fixtures from 458 to 165 watts over 4,000 hours save 70,320 kWh, $8,400 a year at 12 cents, plus $1,500 in maintenance; at $300 net per fixture after a $50 rebate the $18,000 pays back in 1.8 years and nets about $81,000 over ten.

The tool's starting values, and what it returns for them:

Fixtures60
Existing watts per fixture458 W
LED watts per fixture165 W
Hours per year4,000 h
Electricity rate0.12 $/kWh
Lamp and ballast maintenance saved25 $ per fixture per year
Installed cost per fixture350 $
Utility rebate per fixture50 $
Simple payback1.8 years
Saved per year9,938 $
Ten-year net81,384 $
Energy saved per year70,320 kWh
Investment after rebates18,000 $
Demand reduced17.6 kW

Mistakes that catch people

  • Comparing lamp watts instead of fixture watts; the ballast draws 15%.
  • Replacing fixture for fixture when the LED's delivered lumens allow fewer.
  • Leaving the rebate on the table by buying before the utility's pre-approval.

Rules of thumb

  • Metal halide 400 W ≈ LED 150 to 165 W for the same floor light.
  • One shift about 2,500 hours a year, two shifts 5,000, continuous 8,760.
  • Rebates: check the utility before buying; most need the application first.

When to stop calculating and make a call

  • Hazardous or cold storage locations: fixture listings and low-temperature ratings.
  • A full relight: a photometric layout may cut the fixture count.

Questions people ask

What about the demand charge?
If the bill has a $/kW demand charge, the kW reduction shown saves that every month on top of the energy, often 20 to 30% more. Add it to the yearly savings if you know the rate.

Standards and sources

  • U.S. DOE, Lighting retrofit economics; utility rebate programs

This guide and the tool are planning aids. The equipment maker, the engineer of record, the accountant, or the code official confirms the final number for your building.