Line Item SupplyIndustrial Equipment
Request a Quote

Material handling and racking · guide

Electric vs propane forklift cost: the guide

On fuel alone an electric truck runs for a quarter of what a propane truck does; the battery and the purchase price are where propane claws some back.

Open the calculator

Why this number matters

A propane truck burns a 33-pound cylinder in six to eight hours of hard work, about $30 an exchange, and an engine needs oil, filters, plugs, and exhaust work. An electric truck draws about 30 kWh per charge including the charger's losses, $3.60 at 12 cents, and has no engine to maintain. Over 250 shifts the fuel gap alone is about $8,000 a truck a year, and the maintenance gap another $1,000, which is why most indoor fleets have gone electric.

What the calculator does not include is where propane keeps a case: the truck costs less to buy, refuels in two minutes against an hour on a charger or a battery change, works outdoors and on ramps, and does not need a charging room with ventilation and spill containment. The electric truck's battery is a third of the truck's price and lasts five to seven years on one shift, less on three. Lithium batteries change that arithmetic again with opportunity charging and no watering.

Put the running cost difference into the ROI calculator with the price difference and the battery replacement, and the answer for one shift indoors is almost always electric.

How it is figured

  • Propane: cylinders per shift × price × shifts + maintenance. Electric: kWh per charge × 1.15 for charger losses × rate × shifts + maintenance. Battery replacement and the purchase price difference are not included; put them in the payback calculator.

A worked example

A propane truck at 1.2 cylinders a shift and $30 a cylinder, 250 shifts, plus $2,500 of maintenance is $11,500 a year; an electric truck at 30 kWh a charge and 12 cents, plus $1,500 of maintenance, is $2,535, a difference of about $9,000 a year.

The tool's starting values, and what it returns for them:

Propane cylinders per shift1.2
Price per cylinder exchange30 $
kWh per charge30 kWh
Electricity rate0.12 $/kWh
Shifts per year250
Propane truck maintenance2,500 $ per year
Electric truck maintenance1,500 $ per year
Propane truck per year11,500 $
Electric truck per year2,535 $
Electric saves8,965 $ per year
Propane fuel per year9,000 $
Electricity per year1,035 $

Mistakes that catch people

  • Comparing on fuel and forgetting the battery replacement.
  • Counting kWh at the battery and not at the wall; chargers lose 15%.
  • Electric trucks on a yard ramp in the rain.

Rules of thumb

  • Propane: a cylinder per shift, $25 to $35. Electric: 25 to 35 kWh a shift, $3 to $5.
  • Lead-acid batteries: a third of the truck's price every 5 to 7 years.
  • Indoors on one shift: electric wins; outdoors or three shifts with no spare batteries: propane is still in it.

When to stop calculating and make a call

  • Fleet conversions: the dealer's total cost of ownership with your duty cycle and power rate.
  • Charging rooms: ventilation, eyewash, and the electrical service.

Questions people ask

Which is cheaper to run?
Electric, by a wide margin on fuel, in almost every plant with power under 20 cents a kWh; propane keeps the edge on upfront price, refueling in seconds, and outdoor or ramp work. The battery is the electric truck's hidden cost, about a third of the truck's price every 5 to 7 years.

Standards and sources

  • Industrial truck fleet cost studies (ITA, OEM total cost of ownership guides)

This guide and the tool are planning aids. The equipment maker, the engineer of record, the accountant, or the code official confirms the final number for your building.