Metal buildings and structure · guide
R-value and heat loss: the guide
The R-value on the insulation label is not the R-value of the roof once it is draped over purlins; the assembly number is what sets the heat loss and the bill.
Why this number matters
Heat flows through a wall or roof in proportion to the temperature difference and inversely to the resistance of everything in the way: the air film inside, the insulation, the panel, the film outside. The insulation's label R counts only if it is at full thickness, and a single blanket compressed over purlins is not, which is why ASHRAE 90.1 rates a draped R-19 roof at an assembly U of about 0.08, close to what R-13 would give. Liner systems and filled cavities that hold the insulation at full depth below the purlins get the labeled value, and that is the step change in the calculator's before-and-after.
The loss per thousand square feet at the design temperature difference is the number the heater sizing uses; multiplied by the equivalent full-load heating hours for the climate it becomes energy for the year, and at the delivered fuel price it becomes dollars. The saving from an upgrade is the difference, and on a 100,000 square foot roof in the Great Lakes it is tens of thousands a year.
Condensation is the other reason to insulate, covered by the metal roof calculator: the same compressed blanket that loses heat also runs its inside face cold enough to drip.
How it is figured
- Assembly R = insulation R (× 0.6 for a single blanket compressed over purlins, per MBMA and ASHRAE 90.1 assembly tables) + air films (0.68 inside, 0.17 outside). U = 1 ÷ R.
- Heat loss = U × area × temperature difference. Annual energy = that × equivalent full-load heating hours; cost at the delivered price per million BTU.
A worked example
A draped R-10 roof performs at about R-6.9 as an assembly, losing 8,700 BTU/h per thousand square feet at a 60-degree difference; an R-30 liner system loses 1,950, and on 10,000 square feet over 1,500 heating hours the upgrade saves about 100 million BTU and $1,200 a year at $12 per million BTU.
The tool's starting values, and what it returns for them:
| Insulation now | R-10 fiberglass (3 in.) |
| Upgrade to | R-30 liner system |
| Blanket over purlins, compressed | Yes, single layer draped over purlins (about 60% effective) |
| Inside temperature | 65 °F |
| Outside design temperature | 5 °F |
| Roof or wall area | 10,000 sq ft |
| Heating hours per year at this difference | 1,500 h |
| Heat cost | 12 $ per million BTU |
| Assembly R now | 6.9 |
| Heat loss per 1,000 sq ft now | 8,759 BTU/h |
| Upgrade saves per year | 1,227 $ |
| Assembly R after | 30.9 |
| Heat loss per 1,000 sq ft after | 1,945 BTU/h |
| Energy saved per year | 102.2 million BTU |
- A single blanket draped over purlins is compressed to about 60% of its labeled R at the purlins and between; R-10 performs near R-6. Liner systems hold the full value, which is the step change in the numbers above.
Mistakes that catch people
- Specifying the label R and getting the compressed R.
- Comparing the upgrade on the energy price without the delivery and efficiency: gas at $1.20 a therm through an 80% heater is $15 per million BTU, not $12.
- Insulating the roof and leaving the dock doors open.
Rules of thumb
- Draped blanket over purlins: about 60% of the label.
- Air films add about R-0.85 to any assembly.
- U = 1 ÷ R; halving U halves the loss.
When to stop calculating and make a call
- Energy code compliance (ASHRAE 90.1, IECC): the prescriptive tables and the climate zone decide the minimum.
- Re-insulating an occupied building: the vapor retarder and the existing moisture come first.
Questions people ask
- Why does a liner system matter so much?
- Because the blanket is not compressed. A draped R-19 tests near U-0.08 as an assembly; an R-30 liner system near U-0.035, less than half the loss. Energy codes have moved to liner systems or filled cavities for that reason.
Standards and sources
- ASHRAE 90.1, Appendix A, assembly U-factors for metal building roofs and walls
- MBMA Energy Design Guide for Metal Building Systems
This guide and the tool are planning aids. The equipment maker, the engineer of record, the accountant, or the code official confirms the final number for your building.