Line Item SupplyIndustrial Equipment
Request a Quote

Choosing a system

PEMB vs. conventional steel vs. tilt-up: choosing the structure for a commercial building.

Three systems build most single-story commercial and industrial shells. They differ less in the steel or concrete than in who designs it, when the design is finished, and what the building is asked to do. Many projects end up using more than one.

Isometric drawing of a steel building frame being erected with a crane on site

Representative drawing of the equipment type, not the exact configuration quoted.

Who designs what

This is the real difference between a pre-engineered and a structural steel building, and it drives the schedule and the paperwork.

Design responsibility in the three delivery methods
SystemWho designs the structureWhat the others do
Metal building system (PEMB)The building manufacturer's engineer, after the order, as one optimized systemThe engineer of record sets the criteria; a foundation engineer designs from the column reactions
Conventional structural steelThe engineer of record, member by member, before biddingA fabricator details and fabricates to the drawings; joists and deck come from their own suppliers
Tilt-up concreteThe engineer of record designs the wall panels and the roof structureThe contractor casts panels on site and lifts them; a steel roof structure bears on the panels
Isometric drawing of steel frames, purlins, girts, and cross bracing in a new building

Representative drawing of the equipment type, not the exact configuration quoted.

Where a metal building system fits, and where it does not

A metal building is at its best as a single-story building with a regular plan: warehouses, plants, shops, gyms, and flex buildings. The manufacturer's engineer tunes every member to the loads, which is why it is hard to beat on steel weight for that kind of building.

It is a weaker fit as the building departs from that shape. The honest list is below, and on those projects conventional steel, or a mix, is usually the better choice.

  • Irregular plans: curves, many re-entrant corners, or column grids that change from bay to bay
  • Multi-story buildings with full upper floors
  • Heavy floors or heavy concentrated loads that dominate the design
  • Architecture that needs the frame in particular places or shapes for appearance
  • Projects where the structure must be fully designed before a supplier is chosen

Pre-engineered steel vs. tilt-up

Tilt-up walls are concrete panels cast flat on the slab and lifted into place. They are durable, fire-resistant, and secure, and they suit large distribution buildings where the wall area is big enough to justify the casting and lifting operation. The slab has to be in place first, and casting depends on weather.

A metal building's walls are light steel panels on girts. They go up quickly, insulate well with the right system, and are easy to open up for a future door or an addition. They are less resistant to impact and forced entry than concrete, which is why many buildings use a masonry or concrete wall at the bottom or on the dock side.

Hybrid steel buildings

A hybrid steel building combines systems. The common versions are metal building frames and roof with masonry or tilt-up walls on some or all sides, and a conventional steel portion, such as a multi-story office, attached to a metal building plant or warehouse.

Hybrids work when the interface is assigned. Hard walls are brittle compared with steel panels, so the building engineer must be given tighter drift and deflection limits than a metal building's standard, and those limits add steel. The documents also have to say whether the wall carries the roof or the frame does, how the wall is braced against wind by the steel, and who designs the connection between them.

  • State the wall material and height on every side with the request
  • State the drift and deflection limits, or ask the engineer of record for them
  • Say whether hard walls are load-bearing or carried laterally by the steel
  • Put an expansion joint or a clear structural break between a conventional portion and the metal building where the engineer calls for one

Schedule logic

With a metal building, engineering happens after the order. The anchor bolt plan and reactions follow, the foundation is designed from them, and fabrication is released when the approval drawings are returned. Ordering early is what protects the schedule, and the foundation cannot be final until the reactions are.

With conventional steel, the design is complete before bidding, so the foundation can start sooner, but shop drawings, review, and fabrication follow the award. With tilt-up, the slab comes first, then panel casting and lifting, then the roof steel. The quotation states the current timing for the metal building. Ask the fabricator and the concrete contractor for theirs, and compare the three as whole sequences.

Questions for the architect and the engineer of record

Asked early, these settle which system the building wants. When the answer is a metal building or a hybrid, send the drawings and the criteria. Freight to the job site is included in every quotation, the foundation is by others, and erection can be quoted as a separate line on request. The package builder on this site covers the basic dimensions.

  • Do the documents allow a metal building system, and under which specification section?
  • What drift and deflection limits apply, given the wall and ceiling finishes?
  • Are any walls load-bearing masonry or concrete?
  • What collateral loads, rooftop units, and cranes are planned?
  • Is there a multi-story or heavily loaded area better framed conventionally?
  • Who designs the foundation, and when do they need the reactions?
  • Is future expansion planned, and in which direction?

Questions

What is the difference between PEMB and conventional steel?
In a PEMB the building manufacturer engineers the whole steel system after the order, using built-up tapered frames and cold-formed secondary members. In conventional steel the engineer of record designs each member from standard shapes and a fabricator builds to those drawings.
Is a pre-engineered building cheaper than a structural steel building?
For a regular single-story building it usually uses less steel, because every member is sized to its load. That advantage shrinks as the building becomes irregular, multi-story, or heavily loaded. The way to know is to price both from the same criteria.
Can a metal building have tilt-up or masonry walls?
Yes. That is a hybrid, and it is common. The building engineer needs the wall type, its height, whether it carries roof load, and the drift limit required to protect it. Those go on the order.
When is tilt-up a better choice than pre-engineered steel?
When the owner wants concrete walls for durability, security, or fire resistance and the building is large enough to make site casting efficient. Many such buildings still use steel framing for the roof.
Who buys the building on a project like this?
Building packages are sold through contractors and erectors, usually the general contractor or the erector on the project. If you are the owner or the architect, tell us who is building it.