Line Item SupplyIndustrial Equipment
Request a Quote

Choosing a system

Three things are sold as a "metal building". They are not the same.

Search for a metal building and you are shown three different products at very different prices. Each has a job it does well. Most comparisons are written by a company that sells only one of them. This one is written by a dealer that would rather you buy the right one.

Isometric drawing of a long metal building with ribbed wall panels, overhead doors, and a navy wainscot

Representative drawing of the equipment type, not the exact configuration quoted.

The three systems

The difference is the frame.

Rigid-frame, cold-formed, and tube-steel buildings compared
How it is framedWhere it fits
Red iron (rigid frame, PEMB)Welded plate frames, usually tapered, with cold-formed purlins and girtsCommercial and industrial buildings: wide spans, tall eaves, cranes, heavy snow and wind
Cold-formed steelFrames of roll-formed galvanized C and Z sections, boltedShops, storage, and small commercial buildings with modest spans and loads
Tube steel (carport-style)Bent square steel tubing frames on closely spaced bows, sheeted directlyCarports, residential garages, and small utility buildings
Isometric drawing of a bolted end-plate connection where a rafter meets a column, with a flange brace

Representative drawing of the equipment type, not the exact configuration quoted.

The questions that separate them

Is the building engineered for your address? A rigid-frame or cold-formed building from an established manufacturer is designed for the code loads at the job site, with drawings that can be sealed for your state. Tube-steel buildings are often sold from standard designs; some sellers offer site-specific engineering and some do not. Ask for the design loads in writing and ask whether sealed drawings for your jurisdiction are available.

What does the permit office require? Commercial buildings, occupied buildings, and most buildings on a contractor's project need a sealed, site-specific design. That requirement alone usually decides the system.

What does the building carry and how long must it last? Spans, door sizes, snow, wind, hung loads, and future expansion all favor an engineered frame as they grow.

What we sell, and what we do not

We quote rigid-frame and cold-formed building packages through contractors. We do not sell tube-steel carport-style buildings. If that is what your project needs, a local installer of those buildings is the right call, and we will tell you so.

Questions

Why is a tube-steel building so much cheaper?
It uses less steel in lighter members, is often built from a standard design rather than engineered for one site, and is usually installed by the seller's crew in a day or two. For a carport or a small garage that is a sensible product. It is a different product from an engineered commercial building.
Is "certified" the same as engineered for my site?
Not necessarily. Ask what the certification covers: which code, which wind and snow loads, and whether it applies to your address. A sealed drawing for your jurisdiction states those values explicitly.
Is red iron better than cold-formed?
Neither is better in general. Rigid frames are the right tool for large and heavily loaded buildings. Cold-formed frames are the right tool for smaller ones. Both are engineered to the same code loads.